Navigating stormy waters of security risks: Pakistan’s ongoing battle against threats

Terrorism involves the use of threats or violent actions deliberately aimed at influencing governments or intimidating the public to further a specific ideology. This can encompass a wide range of tactics, including bombings, assassinations, kidnappings, and other forms of violence intended to create fear and achieve political, religious, or ideological goals. Terrorism in Pakistan, highlighting its political and ideological roots, the deliberate targeting of civilians, and the broader objectives of instilling fear and impacting governance, it has been a significant and persistent challenge for several decades.
In this article, we will explore the far-reaching impacts of terrorism on Pakistan, focusing on its profound economic toll – from the destruction of critical infrastructure to the erosion of future economic opportunities. Pakistan has been grappling with the scourge of terrorism for over two decades since 2001, country has borne the loss of thousands of lives alongside significant financial repercussions.a comprehensive policy and integrated strategy are essential to address this challenge effectively in the long term. Achieving sustainable success requires the establishment and widespread promotion of a national narrative against terrorism and extremism, especially in the era of digital communication. This narrative should serve as the cornerstone of efforts aimed at countering terrorism and extremism.
The Islamic Republic of Pakistan operates as a federal parliamentary democracy under the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, where elected representatives at national and provincial levels form the government. The Constitution guarantees fundamental rights of all citizens.
The history of terrorism in Asia is characterized by a complex interplay of political, religious, ethnic, and ideological factors spanning several decades. During the Cold War era, Asia witnessed the emergence of leftist insurgencies and nationalist movements, often fueled by external influences and ideological divisions. Post-colonial conflicts and unresolved territorial disputes contributed to the rise of separatist movements in regions like Kashmir in South Asia and Mindanao in Southeast Asia.
The 21st century brought new dynamics with the global War on Terror following the September 11 attacks, significantly impacting Asia. Countries like Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Iraq became focal points in the fight against Al-Qaeda and later, the Taliban insurgency. Ethnic and religious tensions continue to drive terrorism in Asia, with groups exploiting grievances and historical grievances to justify violence. State sponsorship of terrorism, either directly or indirectly through support for proxy groups, further complicates efforts to address the root causes of extremism. Regional cooperation through organizations like ASEAN and bilateral agreements has been crucial in enhancing counterterrorism measures and intelligence sharing across Asia. Terrorism remains a persistent threat in Asia, necessitating ongoing cooperation and holistic strategies to promote peace, stability, and resilience in the region.
In the 1980s, Pakistan underwent significant changes in its socio-political landscape that set the stage for the emergence and escalation of terrorism within its borders. One of the pivotal factors was the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979, which led to Pakistan becoming a key player in the Afghan Mujahideen resistance against the Soviet forces.
During this period, Pakistan, along with support from the United States and other Western countries, provided sanctuary, training, and arms to Afghan Mujahideen groups fighting against the Soviet occupation. This influx of foreign fighters, alongside the militarization of the Afghan-Pakistan border regions, contributed to the proliferation of weapons and militant ideologies within Pakistan.
The year 2001 marked a pivotal turning point for Pakistan as it became a frontline state in the global War on Terror following the September 11 attacks in the United States. In response to the attacks, Pakistan, under the leadership of President Pervez Musharraf, swiftly aligned itself with the international coalition against terrorism led by the United States. This decision brought about a significant shift in Pakistan’s economic and foreign policy priorities.
Pakistan’s support for the US-led coalition included granting logistical and operational support for military operations in neighboring Afghanistan, where the Taliban regime, accused of harboring Al-Qaeda leaders responsible for the 9/11 attacks, came under intense international pressure. The Pakistani military launched operations in the tribal areas along the Pakistan-Afghanistan border, targeting Al-Qaeda and Taliban fighters who had taken refuge there. Internally, Pakistan faced a resurgence of extremism and terrorism, partly fueled by backlash from militant groups opposed to the government’s alliance with the United States.
The country witnessed a wave of terrorist attacks targeting security forces, government installations, and public spaces. These attacks intensified sectarian tensions and posed significant challenges to Pakistan’s internal security and stability. Post 9/11 relations with the US are all assessed from the perspective of Pakistan’s strategic decline as a consequence of multiple factors including economic weakness, domestic discord and strategic confusion (Dr Maleeha Lodhi, Pakistan Beyond the Crisis State).
Pakistan’s military conducted several operations to eliminate militant strongholds, particularly in the tribal areas bordering Afghanistan. Operations such as Operation Enduring Freedom (2001-2014), Operation Rah-e-Nijat (2009), and Operation Zarb-e-Azb (2014) aimed to dismantle terrorist networks and restore government control in affected regions.
Country’s economy suffered significant setbacks due to the conflict and associated security challenges. Economic activities were disrupted, investor confidence was affected, and resources that could have been allocated to development and social welfare were diverted towards security expenditures and reconstruction efforts. In response to these security challenges, Pakistan faced economic pressures that necessitated emergency measures to stabilize the economy. These measures included seeking financial assistance from international organizations like the IMF (International Monetary Fund), implementing austerity measures, and undertaking reforms to address fiscal imbalances and debt sustainability. Pakistan, grappling with economic issues and insecurity, has long relied on external aid to counter perceived existential threats from its neighbors.
The political leadership’s disconnect with popular needs and institutional stagnation has left non-governmental actors, including extremists, to fill critical social roles like education and justice. This has created parallel loyalties that undermine state authority, necessitating external support not only for security but also for institutional development to rebuild public trust. Despite aligning with the US in the war on terror, Pakistan’s partnership is fraught with differing expectations. While it considers itself integral to combating groups like al-Qaeda, the US views Pakistan both as part of the problem and the solution. Nevertheless, Pakistan relies on external assistance to address its internal security challenges and institutional deficiencies.
At the operational level, Pakistan’s law enforcement agencies lack the professionalism needed to tackle the enormity of their tasks. A modernized, proficient police force is essential to ensure internal security and manage the repercussions of Pakistan’s domestic issues effectively.
“Terrorism must be condemned in the strongest terms possible. Not only does it cause destruction and suffering in the short term, but it also perpetuates the cycle of violence and hatred in the long term.” (Nelson Mandela).
Pakistan’s struggle against terrorism has been marked by profound challenges and complexities rooted in historical, geopolitical, and socio-economic factors. Over the decades, the country has faced significant turmoil and loss due to terrorism, impacting its economy, security, and societal cohesion. Efforts to combat terrorism have included military operations, international alliances, and socio-economic reforms aimed at addressing root causes. However, the effectiveness of these efforts has been hindered by political instability, institutional weaknesses, and external pressures.
The country must prioritize comprehensive strategies that encompass not only military responses but also diplomatic engagement, economic development, and social reforms. Strengthening law enforcement, promoting national unity, and countering extremist ideologies are crucial steps towards achieving long-term peace and stability. International cooperation remains essential in addressing cross-border terrorism and ensuring regional security. By fostering a united front against terrorism and fostering a conducive environment for development and prosperity, Pakistan can mitigate the impact of terrorism and pave the way for a more secure and prosperous future.