FBR Revenue Shortfall Highlights Fiscal Challenges

ISLAMABAD: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has reported a revenue collection shortfall of Rs386 billion in the first half of the current fiscal year, primarily due to a decline in imports, sluggish manufacturing growth, and unexpectedly low inflation.

Key Figures and Observations

Revenue Collection Performance

• Target vs. Collection:
  • Target: Rs6.009 trillion (July-Dec)
  • Actual: Rs5.623 trillion (shortfall of Rs386 billion).
  • Despite the shortfall, collection rose 26% from Rs4.466 trillion in the same period last year.
• December Collection:
  • Target: Rs1.373 trillion
  • Actual: Rs1.326 trillion (shortfall of Rs47 billion).
  • December collection increased 35% year-on-year (YoY) from Rs984 billion.

Sectoral Performance

• Income Tax:
  • Exceeded target by Rs256 billion, collecting Rs2.780 trillion (29% growth YoY).
• Sales Tax:
  • Fell short by Rs380 billion, with Rs1.898 trillion collected (25% growth YoY).
• Customs Duties:
  • Fell short by Rs155 billion, with Rs598 billion collected.

Refund Payments

• Total Refunds (July-Dec): Rs273 billion, up 16.66% from Rs234 billion last year.
• December Refunds: Rs70 billion, a significant increase from Rs38 billion in December last year.

Underlying Challenges

1. Ambitious Revenue Targets:
   • FY25 target of Rs12.913 trillion is a 40% increase over FY24, deemed unrealistic by independent economists.
   • Real revenue collection for FY25 is projected to be closer to Rs12 trillion.
2. Economic Factors:
   • Reduced imports due to trade slowdown.
   • Sluggish growth in large-scale manufacturing.
   • Unexpectedly low inflation, now in single digits, affecting tax receipts.
3. Policy Implications:
   • High dependency on imports for tax revenue has magnified the impact of trade decline.
   • Inefficient expenditure control has added pressure on meeting fiscal goals.

Outlook and Government Response

• The government anticipates GDP growth (3%), large-scale manufacturing expansion (3.5%), and import growth (16.9%) to contribute Rs1.863 trillion to revenue in FY25.
• Measures to address the shortfall:
  • Adjustments in autonomous growth.
  • Expenditure reductions instead of new tax measures.
• IMF Monitoring:
  • The IMF’s visit in late February or early March will review progress under the $7 billion Extended Fund Facility (EFF).
  • FBR’s second-quarter tax-to-GDP ratio of 10.8% surpassed the IMF target of 10.6%.

Conclusion

The FBR’s revenue shortfall underscores the challenges of overly ambitious targets amidst economic headwinds. While progress in income tax collection is notable, reliance on imports for tax revenues and the current macroeconomic conditions necessitate a more balanced fiscal strategy. As the IMF review approaches, the government faces the critical task of managing revenue gaps without imposing undue strain on taxpayers or stifling economic growth.

To Keep Updated Visit & Follow our Facebook Page Or Our Website